An artificial intelligence called Libratus beat four top professional poker players in No-Limit Texas Hold'em by breaking the game into smaller, more manageable parts and adjusting its strategy as play progressed during the competition, researchers report.
Normally I just define them as slotted pads in Altium and the board house deals with it. Standard slot as a pad. Usually I just add a pad that's defined as a slot with a very small pad in the middle. This time I was using OSH Park, and as it turned out things were not that easy. Altium board slot.
Libratus: The Superhuman AI for No-Limit Poker (Demonstration) Noam Brown Computer Science Department Carnegie Mellon University Tuomas Sandholm Computer Science Department Carnegie Mellon University and Strategic Machine, Inc. Abstract No-limit Texas Hold'em is the most popular vari-ant of poker in the world. Heads-up no-limit Texas. Libratus is an artificial intelligence computer program designed to play poker, specifically heads up no-limit Texas hold 'em. Libratus' creators intend for it to be generalisable to other, non-Poker-specific applications. It was developed at Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh.
After a 20 day marathon challenge at the Rivers Casino in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, the results of the Brains Vs.Artificial Intelligence: Upping the Ante shocked the whole poker community when the Artificial Intelligence (AI) 'Libratus' beat 4 of the best poker players in the world heads-up in No Limit Texas Holdem. Three-part attack strategy. Libratus, they claim, was able to see off all comers by using the concept of 'Subgame solving', pictured right, which it used to work around a game of imperfect information such as Hold'em.
In a new paper in Science, Tuomas Sandholm, professor of computer science at Carnegie Mellon University, and Noam Brown, a PhD student in the computer science department, detail how their AI achieved superhuman performance in a game with more decision points than atoms in the universe.
AI programs have defeated top humans in checkers, chess, and Go—all challenging games, but ones in which both players know the exact state of the game at all times. Poker players, by contrast, contend with hidden information: what cards their opponents hold and whether an opponent is bluffing.
Imperfect information
In a 20-day competition involving 120,000 hands this past January at Pittsburgh's Rivers Casino, Libratus became the first AI to defeat top human players at Head's-Up, No-Limit Texas Hold'em—the primary benchmark and longstanding challenge problem for imperfect-information game-solving by AIs.
Libratus beat each of the players individually in the two-player game and collectively amassed more than $1.8 million in chips. Measured in milli-big blinds per hand (mbb/hand), a standard used by imperfect-information game AI researchers, Libratus decisively defeated the humans by 147 mmb/hand. In poker lingo, this is 14.7 big blinds per game.
Loading slot. 'The techniques in Libratus do not use expert domain knowledge or human data and are not specific to poker,' Sandholm and Brown write in the paper. 'Thus, they apply to a host of imperfect-information games.'
Such hidden information is ubiquitous in real-world strategic interactions, they note, including business negotiation, cybersecurity, finance, strategic pricing, and military applications.
Three modules
Standard t slot sizes. Libratus includes three main modules, the first of which computes an abstraction of the game that is smaller and easier to solve than by considering all 10161 (the number 1 followed by 161 zeroes) possible decision points in the game. It then creates its own detailed strategy for the early rounds of Texas Hold'em and a coarse strategy for the later rounds. This strategy is called the blueprint strategy.
One example of these abstractions in poker is grouping similar hands together and treating them identically.
'Intuitively, there is little difference between a king-high flush and a queen-high flush,' Brown says. 'Treating those hands as identical reduces the complexity of the game and, thus, makes it computationally easier.' In the same vein, similar bet sizes also can be grouped together.
In the final rounds of the game, however, a second module constructs a new, finer-grained abstraction based on the state of play. It also computes a strategy for this subgame in real-time that balances strategies across different subgames using the blueprint strategy for guidance—something that needs to be done to achieve safe subgame solving. During the January competition, Libratus performed this computation using the Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center's Bridges computer.
When an opponent makes a move that is not in the abstraction, the module computes a solution to this subgame that includes the opponent's move. Sandholm and Brown call this 'nested subgame solving.' DeepStack, an AI created by the University of Alberta to play Heads-Up, No-Limit Texas Hold'em, also includes a similar algorithm, called continual re-solving. DeepStack has yet to be tested against top professional players, however.
Libratus Poker Strategy Rules
How artificial intelligence can teach itself slang
The third module is designed to improve the blueprint strategy as competition proceeds. Typically, Sandholm says, AIs use machine learning to find mistakes in the opponent's strategy and exploit them. But that also opens the AI to exploitation if the opponent shifts strategy. Instead, Libratus' self-improver module analyzes opponents' bet sizes to detect potential holes in Libratus' blueprint strategy. Libratus then adds these missing decision branches, computes strategies for them, and adds them to the blueprint.
AI vs. AI
In addition to beating the human pros, researchers evaluated Libratus against the best prior poker AIs. These included Baby Tartanian8, a bot developed by Sandholm and Brown that won the 2016 Annual Computer Poker Competition held in conjunction with the Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence Annual Conference.
Whereas Baby Tartanian8 beat the next two strongest AIs in the competition by 12 (plus/minus 10) mbb/hand and 24 (plus/minus 20) mbb/hand, Libratus bested Baby Tartanian8 by 63 (plus/minus 28) mbb/hand. DeepStack has not been tested against other AIs, the authors note.
'The techniques that we developed are largely domain independent and can thus be applied to other strategic imperfect-information interactions, including nonrecreational applications,' Sandholm and Brown conclude. 'Due to the ubiquity of hidden information in real-world strategic interactions, we believe the paradigm introduced in Libratus will be critical to the future growth and widespread application of AI.'
To spur innovation, teach A.I. to find analogies
The technology has been exclusively licensed to Strategic Machine Inc., a company Sandholm founded to apply strategic reasoning technologies to many different applications.
In a new paper in Science, Tuomas Sandholm, professor of computer science at Carnegie Mellon University, and Noam Brown, a PhD student in the computer science department, detail how their AI achieved superhuman performance in a game with more decision points than atoms in the universe.
AI programs have defeated top humans in checkers, chess, and Go—all challenging games, but ones in which both players know the exact state of the game at all times. Poker players, by contrast, contend with hidden information: what cards their opponents hold and whether an opponent is bluffing.
Imperfect information
In a 20-day competition involving 120,000 hands this past January at Pittsburgh's Rivers Casino, Libratus became the first AI to defeat top human players at Head's-Up, No-Limit Texas Hold'em—the primary benchmark and longstanding challenge problem for imperfect-information game-solving by AIs.
Libratus beat each of the players individually in the two-player game and collectively amassed more than $1.8 million in chips. Measured in milli-big blinds per hand (mbb/hand), a standard used by imperfect-information game AI researchers, Libratus decisively defeated the humans by 147 mmb/hand. In poker lingo, this is 14.7 big blinds per game.
Loading slot. 'The techniques in Libratus do not use expert domain knowledge or human data and are not specific to poker,' Sandholm and Brown write in the paper. 'Thus, they apply to a host of imperfect-information games.'
Such hidden information is ubiquitous in real-world strategic interactions, they note, including business negotiation, cybersecurity, finance, strategic pricing, and military applications.
Three modules
Standard t slot sizes. Libratus includes three main modules, the first of which computes an abstraction of the game that is smaller and easier to solve than by considering all 10161 (the number 1 followed by 161 zeroes) possible decision points in the game. It then creates its own detailed strategy for the early rounds of Texas Hold'em and a coarse strategy for the later rounds. This strategy is called the blueprint strategy.
One example of these abstractions in poker is grouping similar hands together and treating them identically.
'Intuitively, there is little difference between a king-high flush and a queen-high flush,' Brown says. 'Treating those hands as identical reduces the complexity of the game and, thus, makes it computationally easier.' In the same vein, similar bet sizes also can be grouped together.
In the final rounds of the game, however, a second module constructs a new, finer-grained abstraction based on the state of play. It also computes a strategy for this subgame in real-time that balances strategies across different subgames using the blueprint strategy for guidance—something that needs to be done to achieve safe subgame solving. During the January competition, Libratus performed this computation using the Pittsburgh Supercomputing Center's Bridges computer.
When an opponent makes a move that is not in the abstraction, the module computes a solution to this subgame that includes the opponent's move. Sandholm and Brown call this 'nested subgame solving.' DeepStack, an AI created by the University of Alberta to play Heads-Up, No-Limit Texas Hold'em, also includes a similar algorithm, called continual re-solving. DeepStack has yet to be tested against top professional players, however.
Libratus Poker Strategy Rules
How artificial intelligence can teach itself slang
The third module is designed to improve the blueprint strategy as competition proceeds. Typically, Sandholm says, AIs use machine learning to find mistakes in the opponent's strategy and exploit them. But that also opens the AI to exploitation if the opponent shifts strategy. Instead, Libratus' self-improver module analyzes opponents' bet sizes to detect potential holes in Libratus' blueprint strategy. Libratus then adds these missing decision branches, computes strategies for them, and adds them to the blueprint.
AI vs. AI
In addition to beating the human pros, researchers evaluated Libratus against the best prior poker AIs. These included Baby Tartanian8, a bot developed by Sandholm and Brown that won the 2016 Annual Computer Poker Competition held in conjunction with the Association for the Advancement of Artificial Intelligence Annual Conference.
Whereas Baby Tartanian8 beat the next two strongest AIs in the competition by 12 (plus/minus 10) mbb/hand and 24 (plus/minus 20) mbb/hand, Libratus bested Baby Tartanian8 by 63 (plus/minus 28) mbb/hand. DeepStack has not been tested against other AIs, the authors note.
'The techniques that we developed are largely domain independent and can thus be applied to other strategic imperfect-information interactions, including nonrecreational applications,' Sandholm and Brown conclude. 'Due to the ubiquity of hidden information in real-world strategic interactions, we believe the paradigm introduced in Libratus will be critical to the future growth and widespread application of AI.'
To spur innovation, teach A.I. to find analogies
The technology has been exclusively licensed to Strategic Machine Inc., a company Sandholm founded to apply strategic reasoning technologies to many different applications.
Libratus Poker Strategy Game
The National Science Foundation and the Army Research Office supported this research.
Libratus Poker Strategy
Source: Carnegie Mellon University
